Showing posts with label mainstream. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mainstream. Show all posts

Sunday, 4 November 2012

Key areas in mental health recovery

Current initiatives around mental health focus on three key areas of support, anti-stigma and therapy. A fourth area 'recovery' is also an important part of the debate.

'Recovery' is controversial and misunderstood.  Recovery can be associated with 'cure' and the concept of a 'cure' in mental ill-health is not always helpful.  That is not to say that people with mental health conditions never talk of being cured or completely recovered.  Some do.

The predominant experience of living with a long-term mental health condition is one of managing symptoms and maintaining a life.

So recovery becomes a form of health management that allows for hopes, dreams and aspirations to develop and continue according to an individual's wishes and choices.

Thinking around recovery is intimately linked with ideas and concepts of social inclusion.  These ideas go back a long way.  They have their roots in the civil rights movement.  Activist Rosa Parkes' refusal to vacate a bus seat reserved for whites in Alabama Mississippi in 1955 marks a crucial moment in the history of social inclusion.  In some ways it changed everything.

As recently as the early 2000s social inclusion formed a major part of UK government thinking.  It was developed under the (then) office of the deputy prime minister and had a strong impact on policy and funding streams.

Along with recovery and social inclusion is a third term - 'mainstream'.

Mainstream is a key part of social inclusion and recovery because it is in the mainstream world that someone with a mental health condition is required to live, just as we all are.

With the knowledge that 'recovery takes place regardless of symptoms or problems' (New Horizons 2008), individuals with mental health diagnoses have the right to access mainstream areas without prejudice.  Someone with a mental health condition has dreams, hopes, aspirations and goals and it is only in the mainstream world where these have a chance of realisation.

In line with this thinking and policy-making, a whole body of materials was created in the early 2000s to help organisations make mainstream social inclusion possible.  By the mid-2000s third sector organisation working in mental health were often more likely to receive commissions and funding the more they could show a commitment to promoting mainstream.

The old way of thinking that limited people with long-term conditions to handouts, clinical settings, day centres and drop-ins was fast being re-shaped and re-made.

Mainstream recovery approaches are fast disappearing under the tide of cuts to funding and changes in commissioning.  It is an initiative in danger of being consigned to the category of yet another transitory trend in mental health and social inclusion.  This is despite the fact that referral to mainstream is highly cost-effective and has a deep impact on the lives of individuals.


Wednesday, 25 July 2012

The mainstream venue


For many people with a diagnosis of severe and enduring mental ill-health, there is a strong chance of never being employed again.

There are a variety of reasons for this.  Stigma is often put forward as the main block to obtaining work.  Stigma by employers.  Stigma by societal attitudes.  But there is more to it than stigma.

For a significant group of people with mental health conditions, living a life  outside of employment is part of the diagnosis.  Not only diagnosed with clinical illnesses they are also prescribed 'a career in mental health' (Dr. Pat Deegan).

Stigma is only a small part of the rationale behind this exclusion.  Certainly, stigma in employment is still prevalent.  But there are many steps to employment that people may wish to take before they feel ready for work after illness or hospitalisation.  These steps take in any area of aspiration, goals, hopes and dreams that an individual may feel are appropriate. All of these areas once identified should be in mainstream venues.  No-one is going to reach their hopes and goals from a day centre or a clinical setting.

Do mainstream outlets stigmatize against people with mental health conditions?  No, by and large.  Leave out employment where stigma is alive and well.  But elsewhere - in mainstream venues of all kinds stigma is not the issue.

Should people with long-term mental health conditions disclose this to mainstream venues they wish to access?  Only if they personally wish to do so.  It's the individual's choice and no-one should disclose on their behalf.

Someone might feel that disclosure to a mainstream venue might be beneficial or helpful to their progress in that venue.  There may be a key worker or support worker in place.  But the motive behind accessing a mainstream venue is not for 'support' per se.

The motive for a person with a long-term mental health condition to access mainstream is the same as anyone else.  We go to adult education centres to do courses of our choice.  We go to rehearsal studios to play music with our mates.  We go to art galleries to enjoy art.  We go to gyms to do exercise and get fit.  We go to libraries to check out books, use computers and get information.

The person with a mental health condition who accesses these venues is a consumer along with everyone else.  As such he or she is included within the rights of access, protection and insurance that all venues must provide as part of their service.

Sunday, 20 May 2012

Recovery and mainstream


“Recovery is about building a meaningful and satisfying life, as defined by the person themselves, whether or not there are ongoing or recurring symptoms or problems.”  Shepherd, Boardman and Slade 2008.

There are implications for any mental health recovery programme if it is to take place regardless of  'ongoing symptoms or problems'.  Firstly, it requires that the recovery programme is not determined solely by an individual's clinical diagnosis. Instead, it  must be determined by a person identifying what he or she  needs to build a life that is 'meaningful and satisfying'.

An appropriate service and environment in which this identification can take place needs to be in place to help signpost the journey towards invidual goals and aspirations. Fortunately, there are strategies built in to the care pathway that can enable individuals to identify personal goals and locate the sites in mainstream where hopes and goals can be realised.  Whether these services are commissioned locally and regionally in specific areas is another matter.

It is important that aspirational settings are embedded in mainstream because individual goals are not fulfilled in clinical environments, although they may be identified therein.  It is in mainstream where each and every one of us makes the path to achieving our goals.  Mainstream is where we live, work, learn, create, exercise, develop and grow.  Mainstream venues are the sites where these developments can take place.  Sites that include the arts, sports, education, retailing, volunteering, befriending, family, friends, faith and employment.  It is broadly one or more of these areas that an individual will identify as useful to his or her developmental choices.

When this person-centred practice is backed up by a team that can help direct an individual to the appropriate mainstream setting, then a recovery programme can start in earnest.  It may well be that other settings have helped or continue to help in achieving this - settings such as day services and what used to be referred to as  'sheltered' activities or community projects.  The clinical teams also - assertive outreach, O.T.'s and key workers all contribute to client independence.

It is important that the initial conversation about an individual's mainstream goals and aspirations takes place in a mainstream setting.  This may well be an individual's first re-introduction to the mainstream world after what could have been years of semi-institutional or supported environments.   It is extremely unlikely that the practical hope of achieving mainstream is communicated in a hospital consulting room or even in an individual's own home.  Those areas are associated with support, care and treatment.   Mainstream recovery has to go beyond these boundaries.

So what sort of team can best support an individual when it's not support he or she is requesting but access to goals and self-development?  I would argue that this needs to be provided by a bridge-building team, each member equipped to identify the mainstream venues appropriate to the goals the client has identified.

Mainstream is often achieved indirectly and obliquely.  For example, a client who has identified music as a mainstream goal may not go on to achieve in that field or may change their mind about music as a choice in their recovery.  This can be disappointing for me as arts bridge builder, but it is often the case that these individuals benefit immensely from other aspects of mainstream that the team is able to offer.  I frequently find that some clients who have not engaged through the arts are nonetheless following mainstream goals via the befriending service or through volunteering and sports activities.

Conversely, it can be the case that a client who has been signposted to a music outlet in mainstream, goes on to  achieve goals that go far beyond the initial contact with a music studio or rehearsal room that he or she has requested.  Such clients can and do develop employment and self-employment pathways or go on to further and higher education opportunities.  These goals have been achieved through the initial contact with mainstream and couldn't have been realised any other way.  Mainstream itself will often generate these opportunities for the client independently of the bridge building service.

Because bridge building has the strength to enable an 'oblique' approach, there can be limitless opportunities for motivated clients choosing their recovery pathway.  Even a relapse can only hold up rather than destroy the process.  There are confidence and skill levels that clients develop in mainstream, both from mainstream itself as well as support from peers who accessing the same or similar venues.

Thursday, 22 March 2012

The personalisation agenda

In my review of the year 2010 in this blog I wrote about the crucial importance of the personalisation agenda.  Participants in twenty pilot schemes that took place around the UK have been video-documented  on the NMHDU (National Mental Health Development Unit) under personalisation stories.

The testimonies by service users, carers and family members are very powerful.  They provide formidable evidence of the effectiveness of direct payments for people who happen to have long-term mental health conditions.  Through these individual budgets, the evidence shows individuals getting back control of their lives and making their own choices.  A wide spectrum of individual progress is shown in the videos, with people accessing mainstream routes that lead to a much fuller participation in mainstream living. These pathways can include training, employment,  education, creative arts, volunteering and many others.

What the testimonies show is that the road back to any kind of mainstream life can be a long and demanding one.  Before major steps such as education, training and employment can take place there often need to be baby steps to support the process.  Baby steps which are effectively giant steps. With the help of her  care coordinator Stella wrote her own support plan based on the proposition 'what would you like to be different about your life?'.With Stella's clear plan, her care coordinator told her that 'yes, some of this may well be possible'.  As a result, Stella has progressed to far greater independence and confidence levels, managing her home life, using a computer and getting out and about on her new bicycle.  These small steps are testimony to how mainstream life and recovery can take place - with support, with a budget and by looking at the whole person and her individual choices and plans.

From the vantage point of 2011 and this year, it is clear that the personalisation agenda has pretty much been scrapped.  The enlightened key workers who helped enable this to  happen for service users are probably still able to continue the support.  For new service user applicants, it is unlikely that direct payments will be an option.  This may not be true in all parts of the UK, but from my experience it is unfortunately the case.  In many areas personalisation for mental health is completely misunderstood.

In the south London borough of Merton for example, direct payments for mental health service users has only happened in a few individual cases for people who were historically fortunate enough to have an enlightened key worker.

Contacing the direct payments' users group in Merton will shockingly reveal that the entire lobbying process revolves around individual budgets for people with physical needs.  The idea that direct payments can be used to enable independence and access to mainstream life for people with mental health needs is entirely off the radar.

In the meantime, new mental health applicants for incapacity benefit or its equivalent are routinely turned down and categorised as fit for work.  It's a game.  You get turned down and then you appeal where you may just as routinely get the the decision reversed.  Your file may have been sent on to any number of offices, often in other regions of the UK far from where you happen to reside.  Divide and rule.

What the personalisation stories show is that the journey back to mainstream activities has to be done holistically.  The road back to employment for example may take months and years in many cases.  It needs to start with small steps - participation in a creative activity, sport, exercise, I.T. training, volunteering, returning to a church, mosque or temple, meeting people, getting out and about.

The blunt instrument of assessing people with mental health conditions as fit or unfit for work would be funny if it wasn't so tragically grotesque.  As Christian testifies: sitting in the day centre for seventeen years meant that I had 'no interaction with the outside world.  I was so isolated'.  Like Della, Christian wrote down his goals which included things like 'going shopping on my own', 'studying maths' and 'doing cooking, ironing and cleaning'.  It took Christian around ten months to  get direct payments with the help and support of his mum.  As a result, he has a personal assistant Denise who is there to support with his road to independence.  At the time of filming, Christian felt that he had achieved more in the last two years than in the previous seventeen.

Individual  budgets for people with long-term mental health conditions does not always require the involvement of a personal assistant.  Many service users can access a mainstream activity of their own choice simply with the help of a bridge builder or someone who can signpost the individual to an appropriate mainstream venue.  As a bridge builder myself I have done it many times.  Often the client  only requires that initial introduction and then chooses to run with it him or herself.  The beauty of the direct mainstream approach is that it allows anyone who chooses to access their right to a niche in mainstream.  All service providers, whether commercial, retail, community or statutory-based, must under the law extend their contract of duty to everyone who wishes to access their services or products.  This most certainly includes people who may happen to have long-term mental health conditions.

Saturday, 3 March 2012

Peer support workers

A good deal of discussion is taking place around the idea of peer support workers in mental health practice.  A recent Guardian article entitled 'Putting the lunatics in charge of the asylum' has highlighted the debate.

It's not just the 'asylum', hospital, day centre or residential setting where peer support working can take place.  Nor does a peer support or recovery worker have to be an official post, paid or voluntary within the NHS or any clinical setting.

Peer support in mental health is taking place informally all over the place.  Many peer supporters would not even give themselves such a title.  In many cases they are simply spending time with the friends they already know or with the peers who have accessed a setting or venue which attracts them too.

As a bridge builder who has signposted people with severe and enduring mental health diagnoses to mainstream settings of their own choice, I have witnessed this peer support happen over and again.

Four years ago I signposted a client to a mainstream recording studio.  With the help of direct payments he has been accessing this venue weekly ever since, practising guitar and collaborating with others in the studio.  He has also secured part-time employment as a studio assistant, getting the rehearsal rooms ready for bands and bookings.

What has happened as a result of this client's involvement is an informal cascading of peer support and group participation.  Again, this has occurred with very little prompting from the bridge builder.  As my client relishes working with other musicians, he is happy to have peers who also wish to participate i.e. start a band during his weekly studio sessions.  This has resulted in a drummer peer and a singer peer rehearsing regularly together with Bernie (not his real name).  Another peer also attends regularly - a long-term friend of Bernie who is learning guitar from him and who has previously been impossible to place by the bridge building team in any mainstream setting.

This is informal and highly effective peer support.  Above all, it is taking place in mainstream not in any clinical, residential or daycare setting.  Recovery that takes place in mainstream allows for hope, confidence, friendship, group projects and routes to employment.

Wednesday, 18 January 2012

Mainstream in 2012

The future of the mainstream approach in mental health recovery is bleak.  Once pioneered as the most radical yet realistic approach to the care pathway, mainstream has now been side-lined and pushed into a corner.

The thinking behind mainstream in mental health is simple.  Linking up individuals with mainstream areas of their own choice as part of recovery.  Social domains cover a wide spectrum: the arts, employment, volunteering, sport and healthy living, faith, worship or spirituality, employment, self-employment, education and business.

In 2012, the cuts in mental health provision are going deep and are across the board.  Employment is touted as a be-all and end-all yet employment often only happens through a gradual re-introduction to mainstream living .  This is especially true for people who are in secondary mental health care with a 'severe and enduring' diagnosis.

The outcomes that have been attained by individuals who have been referred or self-referred to a mainstream service are often formidable.  Access to mainstream arts providers such as music recording studios, visual arts courses or creative writing workshops have led to individuals succeeding in employment, self-employment, higher education and collaborative enterprises with their peers.

The mainstream approach goes far beyond therapies and this blog contains many examples of its success. 

Mainstream is based on recovery as opposed a 'cure'.  It is also based on the individual claiming his or her right to mainstream living along with everyone else.

The opportunity to access mainstream on his or her own terms is not denied to an individual with a 'severe and enduring' mental health diagnosis. Mainstream can be highly supportive of clients' individual aspirations and self-development. Sometimes this encouragement comes directly from the mainstream outlet itself rather than being dictated by carers, statutory services or voluntary agencies. What can be denied and often is, is the opportunity to access the opportunities in the first place.

In many cases, an individual with a 'severe and enduring' mental health diagnosis will only have the chance to access a mainstream activity if it is built in to his or her care pathway and recovery plan.  The professionals who can help signpost people to such activities will be skilled in allowing individuals to identify personal goals and aspirations.  They will also need skills in knowing exactly where the mainstream sites are where an individual can develop and pursue his or her aspirations.   Linking someone up with a mainstream activity of his or her own choice allows that mainstream venue to provide exactly what it is already providing for its clients, users and consumers. 

The client with a mental health diagnosis will be treated no differently from anyone else, unless he or she has specificied particular adjustments.  That too is part of person-centred planning, with individuals free to disclose or not as they deem fit.

There are sound reasons for mainstream being a lot less discriminatory and stigmatizing than it can be portrayed. Mainstream allows individuals to access services as consumers with consumer rights. If someone with a mental health diagnosis freely chooses to develop his or her aspirations in a mainstream environment, there is no good reason why that person should be denied any of the services that particular venue may provide. The client is accessing mainstream as a consumer of that service, not as a 'diagnosis'. 

Once a firm relationship with mainstream has been established, there are multiple ways that mainstream finds to continue to develop individual hopes, dreams and aspirations. I have clients who have found employment through accessing music by rehearsing regularly in a mainstream recording studio. Others have opted to join higher and further education outlets to progress with their dream. Yet others have become volunteers in an environment they enjoy. This has not happened because I have requested the venue to provide employment for my clients Far from it - the venue itself often instigates the process or helps provide the signposting. In many cases this can lead an individual towards a working role in the environment where he or she happens to feel most fulfilled.

This is the viral effect of mainstream

Thursday, 3 November 2011

Is anti-stigma the new stigma?

The 'Time to Change' campaign challenges stigma and discrimination against people with mental health conditions. Time to Change is helping groups and individuals organise activities which actively cooperate in challenging discriminatory attitudes and behaviours.

Challenging discrimination is achieved primarily through engaging in mainstream as a contributor, a consumer or a provider. Many people with mental health conditions access mainstream activities, making their own choices as to whether to disclose or not. The greatest impact in challenging mainstream can be achieved by prioritising individual goals and aspirations. Support is also available to access mainstream from mental health organisations and bridge builders or through personalisation and direct payments.

'Time to Change' seems to insist that all people with mental health conditions wish to disclose as part of their eligibility for mainstream life. In a recent campaign video the broadcaster and service user Stephen Fry asserts that stigma and the attitudes of society in general are the main roadblocks that hinder the self-development of people with mental health conditions.

But many individuals with mental health diagnoses are accessing mainstream life without stigma, whether they choose to disclose or not. Disclosure is really up to the individual and far from discouraging service users to use mainstream, many organisations are open to all and are accessed by people with mental health conditions every day of the week. These are not simply voluntary organisations or groups limited to the health or charity sectors. These are consumer providers of all kinds - art galleries, libraries, recording studios, performance venues, gyms, sports centres, retail outlets and many more. To assert these these organisations are discriminating simply isn't fair on these groups, nor is it a realistic assessment.

Where people with mental health conditions may lose out is in having the initial confidence to set on the journey back to mainstream. This is particularly true of those who have been in secondary care and who may have become habituated to the life that Pat Deegan calls 'a career in mental health'. Dr. Deegan is referring to the lack of hope, aspiration and goals that can set in with hospitalisation or a long-term condition.

People who play football who happen to have mental health conditions are footballers. They aren't required to be 'positive mental health footballers'. People who play guitar who happen to have mental health conditions are guitarists, not mental health guitarists. People who are arts tutors who have a mental health condition are arts tutors. By continuing to tag mental health on mainstream activities and aspirations there is a danger of recycling stigma and not allowing people to move into valued social roles.

Could anti-stigma be the new stigma?

Friday, 30 September 2011

No symptoms, no problems

“Recovery is about building a meaningful and satisfying life, as defined by the person themselves, whether or not there are ongoing or recurring symptoms or problems.” Shepherd, Boardman and Slade 2008.

There are implications for any mental health recovery programme if it is to take place regardless of 'ongoing symptoms or problems'. Firstly, it requires that the recovery programme is not determined solely by an individual's clinical diagnosis. Instead, it must be determined by a person identifying what he or she needs to build a life that is 'meaningful and satisfying'.

An appropriate service and environment in which this identification can take place needs to be in place to help signpost the journey towards invidual goals and aspirations. Fortunately, there are strategies built in to the care pathway that can enable individuals to identify personal goals and locate the sites in mainstream where hopes and goals can be realised. Whether these services are commissioned locally and regionally in specific areas is another matter.

It is important that aspirational settings are embedded in mainstream because individual goals are not fulfilled in clinical environments, although they may be identified therein. It is in mainstream where each and every one of us makes the path to achieving our goals. Mainstream is where we live, work, learn, create, exercise, develop and grow. Mainstream venues are the sites where these developments can take place. Sites that include the arts, sports, education, retailing, volunteering, befriending, family, friends, faith and employment. It is broadly one or more of these areas that an individual will identify as useful to his or her developmental choices.

When this person-centred practice is backed up by a team that can help direct an individual to the appropriate mainstream setting, then a recovery programme can start in earnest. It may well be that other settings have helped or continue to help in achieving this - settings such as day services and what used to be referred to as 'sheltered' activities or community projects. The clinical teams also - assertive outreach, O.T.'s and key workers all contribute to client independence.

It is important that the initial conversation about an individual's mainstream goals and aspirations takes place in a mainstream setting. This may well be an individual's first re-introduction to the mainstream world after what could have been years of semi-institutional or supported environments. It is extremely unlikely that the practical hope of achieving mainstream is communicated in a hospital consulting room or even in an individual's own home. Those areas are associated with support, care and treatment. Mainstream recovery has to go beyond these boundaries.

So what sort of team can best support an individual when it's not support he or she is requesting but access to goals and self-development? I would argue that this needs to be provided by a bridge-building team, each member equipped to identify the mainstream venues appropriate to the goals the client has identified.

Regular readers of this blog will know that I am an arts and faith bridge builder based in south London. Readers will also know that I work directly with people referred from secondary care, that is people with what are called 'severe and enduring' mental health diagnoses. I work with colleagues who are all trained in identifying the mainstream areas appropriate to their bridge building roles. The employment advisor must know about mainstream employment, the sports bridge builder about sports venues, the arts bridge builder must know about the arts locally and regionally.

Mainstream is often achieved indirectly and obliquely. For example, a client who has identified music as a mainstream goal may not go on to achieve in that field or may change their mind about music as a choice in their recovery. This can be disappointing for me as arts bridge builder, but it is often the case that these individuals benefit immensely from other aspects of mainstream that the team is able to offer. I frequently find that some clients who have not engaged through the arts are nonetheless following mainstream goals via the befriending service or through volunteering and sports activities.

Conversely, it can be the case that a client who has been signposted to a music outlet in mainstream, goes on to achieve goals that go far beyond the initial contact with a music studio or rehearsal room that he or she has requested. Such clients can and do develop employment and self-employment pathways or go on to further and higher education opportunities. These goals have been achieved through the initial contact with mainstream and couldn't have been realised any other way. Mainstream itself will often generate these opportunities for the client independently of the bridge building service.

Because bridge building has the strength to enable an 'oblique' approach, there can be limitless opportunities for motivated clients choosing their recovery pathway. Even a relapse can only hold up rather than destroy the process. The confidence and skill levels that clients develop in mainstream enhance growth into further mainstream activities and domains.

Wednesday, 24 August 2011

Music production in mainstream



Music production courses in Morden London are enabling Imagine clients to make a return to mainstream life through things they feel passionate about.

Sunday, 31 July 2011

Building a meaningful life

“Recovery is about building a meaningful and satisfying life, as defined by the person themselves, whether or not there are ongoing or recurring symptoms or problems.”  Shepherd, Boardman and Slade 2008.

There are implications for any mental health recovery programme if it is to take place regardless of  'ongoing symptoms or problems'.  Firstly, it requires that the recovery programme is not determined solely by an individual's clinical diagnosis. Instead, it  must be determined by a person identifying what he or she  needs to build a life that is 'meaningful and satisfying'.

An appropriate service and environment in which this identification can take place needs to be in place to help signpost the journey towards invidual goals and aspirations. Fortunately, there are strategies built in to the care pathway that can enable individuals to identify personal goals and locate the sites in mainstream where hopes and goals can be realised.  Whether these services are commissioned locally and regionally in specific areas is another matter.

It is important that aspirational settings are embedded in mainstream because individual goals are not fulfilled in clinical environments, although they may be identified therein.  It is in mainstream where each and every one of us makes the path to achieving our goals.  Mainstream is where we live, work, learn, create, exercise, develop and grow.  Mainstream venues are the sites where these developments can take place.  Sites that include the arts, sports, education, retailing, volunteering, befriending, family, friends, faith and employment.  It is broadly one or more of these areas that an individual will identify as useful to his or her developmental choices.

When this person-centred practice is backed up by a team that can help direct an individual to the appropriate mainstream setting, then a recovery programme can start in earnest.  It may well be that other settings have helped or continue to help in achieving this - settings such as day services and what used to be referred to as  'sheltered' activities or community projects.  The clinical teams also - assertive outreach, O.T.'s and key workers all contribute to client independence.

It is important that the initial conversation about an individual's mainstream goals and aspirations takes place in a mainstream setting.  This may well be an individual's first re-introduction to the mainstream world after what could have been years of semi-institutional or supported environments.   It is extremely unlikely that the practical hope of achieving mainstream is communicated in a hospital consulting room or even in an individual's own home.  Those areas are associated with support, care and treatment.   Mainstream recovery has to go beyond these boundaries.

So what sort of team can best support an individual when it's not support he or she is requesting but access to goals and self-development?  I would argue that this needs to be provided by a bridge-building team, each member equipped to identify the mainstream venues appropriate to the goals the client has identified.

Regular readers of this blog will know that I am an arts and faith bridge builder based in south London.

Readers will also know that I work directly with people referred from secondary care, that is people with what are called 'severe and enduring' mental health diagnoses.  I work with colleagues who are all trained in identifying the mainstream areas appropriate to their bridge building roles.  The employment advisor must know about mainstream employment, the sports bridge builder about sports venues, the arts bridge builder must know about the arts locally and regionally.

Mainstream is often achieved indirectly and obliquely.  For example, a client who has identified music as a mainstream goal may not go on to achieve in that field or may change their mind about music as a choice in their recovery.  This can be disappointing for me as arts bridge builder, but it is often the case that these individuals benefit immensely from other aspects of mainstream that the team is able to offer.  I frequently find that some clients who have not engaged through the arts are nonetheless following mainstream goals via the befriending service or through volunteering and sports activities.

Conversely, it can be the case that a client who has been signposted to a music outlet in mainstream, goes on to  achieve goals that go far beyond the initial contact with a music studio or rehearsal room that he or she has requested.  Such clients can and do develop employment and self-employment pathways or go on to further and higher education opportunities.  These goals have been achieved through the initial contact with mainstream and couldn't have been realised any other way.  Mainstream itself will often generate these opportunities for the client independently of the bridge building service.

Because bridge building has the strength to enable an 'oblique' approach, there can be limitless opportunities for motivated clients choosing their recovery pathway.  Even a relapse can only hold up rather than destroy the process.  There are confidence and skill levels that clients develop in mainstream that will stand them in good stead.

Tuesday, 12 July 2011

Obliquity in Mental Health

Formulated by economic theorist and author John Kay, obliquity is the notion that complex goals are often best achieved indirectly. As Kay puts it 'happiness is the product of fulfilment in work and private life, not the repetition of pleasurable actions, so happiness is not achieved by pursuing it'.

Kay is hailed widely as a perceptive business and organisational guru, but his ideas have a great deal of relevance in the mental health field.

Kay is very strong on the question of goals and defining business and personal objectives. However his take is interesting as he does not have a straightforward linear viewpoint.

'We find out about the real nature of our goals in the process of accomplishing them, and our understanding of the complex structures of personal relationships or business organisations is necessarily incomplete', Kay writes.

John Kay underlines the importance of goals and goal-setting, which is commonplace in most business and personal development thinking. But he emphasises that even when we set clear goals, we only 'find out about the real nature of our goals in the process of accomplishing them'.

Nothing could be more true when this perception is applied to mental health, recovery and mainstream.

As a social inclusion bridge builder, I am employed to help enable clients set clear goals and prioritise a personal route into and through the mainstream environment. But even when a client has prioritised one specific pathway, it can sometimes be the case that this will not be the area of mainstream that he or she will end up pursuing.

I have clients who have prioritised music or the arts but who soon find a place elsewhere - in sports, volunteering or employment, for example.

It used to be somewhat discouraging to find that clients were not engaging in their originally prioritised mainstream domains. Now I check with other members of the bridge building team and find that many of my original referrals are now active in other areas.

Obliquity in action!

As John Kay puts it: 'the paradox of obliquity is all around us'.

Friday, 22 April 2011

Roadblocks in Mainstream

For many years mainstream has been perceived and practised as a key component of the care pathway in mental health provision.

At several stages of the pathway into mainstream there are roadblocks.  These can occur from the individual client, from services, even from families and carers. An individual can feel apprehensive of stepping over the threshold into mainstream activities.  This can be for a variety of reasons, ranging from self-stigma or from being so long in the mental health system that independence seems a very distant option.  Contrary to some current opinion, it is not stigma from mainstream society that creates the main roadblock.

Dr. Pat Deegan's belief is that too often the health system can encourage what she calls 'a career in mental health' and nothing else.  This viewpoint is based on her experience as a service user and it still holds true.

A great deal is being achieved by service users themselves to challenge the roadblocks.  This is particularly true where creative and personalised use of direct payments and individual budgets have really taken off around the UK.  It hasn't happened everywhere but some immensely inspiring stories and testimonials can be viewed at the NMHDU website. 

Creative use of direct payments in mental health recovery is currently sporadic.  The intention was that this should increase towards full implementation of the personalisation programme.  Invididual budgets were scheduled to become the engine for much healthcare practice all over the UK by 2013.  However, this is now completely overshadowed and possibly lost permanently, in the thrust towards GP consortia and budget management.

Alongside the sudden disappearance of direct payments is the disappearing access to therapies, both for primary and secondary care patients.  Secondary care clients have often lost out in the therapies scenario for a variety of reasons.  But clients in primary care are still entitled to a reasonably smooth road to psychological therapies.  Entitlement does not ensure that those therapy services are available and in practice these too are disappearing along with personalisation and individual budgets.

Of course any client is free to fund their own mainstream recovery pathway and many do. The outcomes in this area alone (south-west London) have often been formidable.  A composer who has funded her own recordings and launches now has self-employment through her music.  Many are those who have accessed adult education courses and further training.  Individuals have re-accessed faith venues which they had previously felt unable to enter for many years. 

Not all these initiatives require direct payments - anyway those have now dried up.  Many activities are free to access or funded by individual clients from their own pockets.  Where direct payment has been needed it has often made the crucial difference. 

Third-sector organisations also do great work in promoting access to mainstream through a variety of initiatives.  'Emergence' is an arts group run by and for service users who are also visual artists.  In London and around the country 'Emergence' has pioneered access to visual arts as well as giving a platform for creativity and exhibition spaces for artists with personality disorder. 

'Imagine' in south west London and Surrey also promotes a variety of arts opportunities including music production and visual arts.  These are open to service users but take place in mainstream settings.

Mainstream environments have their own health, safety and insurance policies.  As a consumer, the service user to entitled to the protection of these policies along with every other mainstream customer and client.

Friday, 18 March 2011

Clinical and social models of care

In the mental health field, it has long been accepted that clinical and social models of care go hand-in-hand.  Doing more than simply addressing clinical symptoms is a requirement of the care pathway. 

People who have experienced severe and enduring mental health conditions currently have access to a spectrum of professionals.  These range from the psychiatrist, the community mental health nurse, assertive outreach and social workers, O.T.s and other key personnel.  Any or all of these individuals can currently form part of the care plan for people recovering from severe mental health conditions.  In addition, there is access to third-party groups providing bridge building or similar services.  The return to mainstream life based on individual choices forms a strong part of the clinical and social models working together.

So what will be the scenario when mental health moves into the sphere of general practice, along with a host of other clinical services? 

In the UK, GP consortia are being set up with the intention of taking over from the primary care teams entirely by the year 2013. The primary care teams that currently incorporate a spectrum of care services for mental health will no longer exist.  It is uncertain whether GP consortia and GP surgeries will be equipped to respond to providing the clinical and social models which currently operate for people with 'severe and enduring' diagnoses.  What this means is that there could be no access to the key services that are well-positioned to provide access for the individual to his or her independence, recovery and self-development. 

The providers who currently enable access to mainstream life for people with mental health conditions will need to introduce themselves to the GP consortia as a matter of urgency.  In order to become better placed to continue the work of mainstream recovery it will be important to do this now.  Commercial and private providers are already muscling in on the GP consortia and it is unlikely that these groups will have any expertise at all in providing hope and aspiration for marginalised people.

Friday, 4 March 2011

What does Pat Deegan mean by a 'career in mental health'?

When Dr. Pat Deegan coined  the phrase 'a career in mental health' she was referring to endemic features of the mental health system prevailing at the time when she was first clincially diagnosed. A 'career in mental health' was the path that her specialists advised would become her future.  It would mean a life on benefits, no chance of employment and massively limited access to opportunities.  It would mean an end to her aspirations, and end to her hopes. Effectively, the end of a career.

For people who have been through secondary mental health experiences in the UK, a 'career in mental health' can still be the norm.  Huge inroads have been made nonetheless.  The recovery programmes that have been set up by many clinical teams all around the country.  The user-led services that are widely encouraged and supported.  The involvement in recruiting people who have experienced mental health conditions  for employment within services.  The movement from supported accommodation to independent living.  The emphasis on mainstream by third-sector organisations working alongside the NHS and statutory services.  The 'paths to personalisation' programme and the independence-based use of direct payments and personal budgets. 

These initiatives and more continue to help enable people with severe and enduring diagnoses to find personal autonomy and make a break from the pitifully bleak reality of Deegan's appositely-described 'career in mental health'. 

But what of the future?

In the UK we are witnessing the root-and-branch dismantling of mental health services as they currently stand.  There will be no more primary care teams and more and more people are being discharged from CMHTs (Community Mental Health Teams).  Within two years consortia of GPs and general practice surgeries will become the budget-holders both for primary and secondary mental health care. 

At this stage there is no way of telling whether these changes will be for the better or for the worse.  The only implacable fact is change itself, massive and across the board.

The fallout from the first tremors of change is already with us.  The much-vaunted personalisation programme was due to be rolled out universally throughout the UK within 18 months. Now it is unlikely to happen at all.  Personal budgets could well be forgotten in the midst of the general upheaval of services.  Certainly, direct payments for mental health have become a thing of the past, at least in the south-west London borough where I work as a bridge builder. This is despite service users having a legal right to direct payments where these can be shown to be a strong factor in their recoveries. 

The experience of personalisation in other parts of the UK may well be different and could paint a much more hopeful picture.  Unfortunately, in the tsunami of change it won't last.

Saturday, 22 January 2011

Obliquity in Mental Health


Formulated by economic theorist and author John Kay, obliquity is the notion that complex goals are often best achieved indirectly.  As Kay puts it 'happiness is the product of fulfilment in work and private life, not the repetition of pleasurable actions, so happiness is not achieved by pursuing it'.

Kay is hailed widely as a perceptive business and organisational guru, but his ideas have a great deal of relevance in the mental health field.

Kay is very strong on the question of goals and defining business and personal objectives.  However his take is interesting as he does not have a straightforward linear viewpoint.

'We find out about the real nature of our goals in the process of accomplishing them, and our understanding of the complex structures of personal relationships or business organisations is necessarily incomplete', Kay writes.

John Kay underlines the importance of goals and goal-setting, which is commonplace in most business and personal development thinking.  But he emphasises that even when we set clear goals, we only 'find out about the real nature of our goals in the process of accomplishing them'.

Nothing could be more  true when this perception is applied to  mental health, recovery and mainstream.

As a social  inclusion bridge builder, I am employed to help enable clients set clear goals and prioritise a personal route into and through the mainstream environment.  But even when a client has prioritised one specific pathway, it can sometimes be the case that this will not be the area of mainstream that he or she will end up pursuing.

I have clients who have prioritised music or the arts but who soon find a place elsewhere - in sports, volunteering or employment, for example.

It used to be somewhat discouraging to find that clients were not engaging in their originally prioritised mainstream domains.  Now I check with other members of the bridge building team and find that many of my original referrals are now active in other areas.

Obliquity in action!

As John Kay puts it: 'the paradox of obliquity is all around us'.

Friday, 7 January 2011

Social Inclusion - so good for business

The business case for mental health awareness is evidenced by the increasing numbers of employers who are commissioning mental health awareness trainings for their workforce. Employers want trainings which enable their staff to understand more about common mental health conditions. Understanding mental health means that staff can work better with clients and customers. It also allows staff to feel less isolated about personal issues around health and well-being.

Mental health awareness provides the opportunity for employers and employees to find out more about the law as it relates to employment and mental health.

Enlightened employers will seek to develop a workforce team which is happy rather than unhappy, fulfilled rather than excluded. Courses such as MHFA (Mental Health First Aid) show that attendees often feel that one of the benefits of the training in that it allows for a safe space. A safe space where individuals can share feelings about their personal well-being in addition to learning about the broader aspects of mental health conditions and the appropriate interventions.

In addition to mental health, it makes solid sense for businesses to incorporate awareness of social inclusion and mainstream. Returning to or accessing mainstream living is now a key part of the care pathway for those diagnosed with 'severe and enduring' mental health diagnoses. It is equally important for people who may be experiencing conditions such as anxiety, phobia or stress at work.

Both groups - those in primary and secondary care - are being signposted to mainstream life rather than to special settings as a central plank of the recovery process. The implications for any service provider - and that includes businesses - are crucial. Businesses and services are at the receiving end of mainstream.

Clients in recovery are choosing to access their personal goals through a diverse range of outlets. These could range from faith venues to volunteer bureaus, from retail outlets to sports centres, from recording studios to adult education colleges, from libraries to personal counselors, from training venues to department stores.

For businesses, it's not just one in four of their staff who may be experiencing mental health challenges, it's also one in four of their clients, customers and service consumers. Mental health challenges will also have an impact on one in three families. Disclosed or undisclosed, it's clear that mental health and well-being lie at the heart of our transactions and interactions.

Tuesday, 21 December 2010

Mental Health 2010 - Review of the Year 2010 part II


Questions

What was the mental health scene like in 2010 for those at the grittier end of the stick?  What was 2010 like for people in secondary care?  For people under community mental health teams?

Was there more recovery in 2010?  Were people in secondary care able to access mainstream more in 2010?  Were they less doomed to what Dr. Pat Deegan calls 'a career in mental health'?

Did people with severe and enduring mental  health conditions receive enough support from services? Did they receive the right support? Did the support help them or hinder them?

Some answers

Throughout 2010, statutory and voluntary services responded to the health challenge of independence and mainstream in several key ways.  Firstly, mental health teams set up some important initiatives.  These were geared towards client independence and recovery.  Many predominantly service-user led.

Recovery University in the south-west London borough of Merton enables secondary care  clients to access a wide spectrum of trainings and skillsets.  These include preparing for work, independence and life skills, confidence building, anger management and  many more.  Recovery University also trains service users as trainers for forthcoming courses.

Other community initiatives are also up and running, including wellbeing programmes and access to psychological therapies.  However, pyschological therapies in non-clinical settings are still not available should you happen to have a severe and enduring mental health condition.

Training the trainers often draws upon experiences and qualifications which service users have already gained within their life journeys.  Mainstream groups have also utilised service user skills as part of their own training programmes in areas such as visual  arts, music and creative writing.  This has taken the recovery university one stage further, providing paid employment and access to mainstream.

Statutory services continued to  have success in keeping people out of hospital or limiting hospital stays to a minimum.   The downside of this is that more and more people are being discharged from statutory services altogether.  In 2011 this will inevitably result in more pressure on GP services, as it is these practitioners who will become responsible under the latest government directives.

The rolling-out of the personalisation programme should mean more access to direct payments for many clients under mental health care plans.  It should also mean more and more creative uses of direct payments, as DP is being promoted for any activity or outcome that a client deems relevant to his or her recovery.  The Personal Stories videos on the NMHDU site bears witness to some of these outcomes.  With more and more people being discharged from mental health services, it is crucial that personalisation is a success in the new year.